Source: William Berry Lapham, History of Rumford, Oxford County, Maine: from its first settlement in 1779 to the present time (Augusta Me.: Press of the Maine Farmer, 1890).
[p. 141]List of Members.The following is a list of the persons who became members of the Congregational church from its organization in eighteen hundred and three: Joshua Graham, Benj. Farnum, Hezekiah Hutchins, Sarah Farnum, Betsey Whittemore, Polly Hinkson, Sally Hutchins, Olive Hinkson, Polly Elliot, Nathaniel F. Higgins, John Whittemore, Dolly Rolfe, Robert Hinkson, Isabel Knapp, Sally Bunker, Jacob Abbot, Stilson Eastman, Mehitable Eastman, Abigail Elliot, Benjamin Elliot, Elias Bartlett, David Hutchins, Caleb Eastman, Hannah Hutchins, Sally Silver, Nathan Adams, Isaac Walker Cleasby, Molly Glines, Mary Hinkson, Asa Howard, Lydia Howard, Hannah Hall, Dr. Elisha Howe, widow Mary Knight, Chloe Farnum, Sarah Hall, Mary Virgin, Aaron Virgin, Comfort Eastman, Hannah Graham, Dolly Morse, Dorothy Dolly, John Bunker, Abel Wheeler, Cotton Elliot, Ephraim Carter, Mary Cleasby, Gratia Elliot, Lois Elliot, Susanna Hoyt, Eliza Adams, Patty Hemmenway, Daniel Gould, Eunice Gould, John Dane, Sarah Dane, Sally Morse, James H. Withington, Betsey Abbot, Phebe Sutton, Mary Adams, Sarah Virgin, Mary Greenleaf, Betty Farnum, Jeremiah Glines, Mrs. Gurgins, Jeremiah Virgin, Jane Virgin, Moses Gould, John[p. 142]Wheeler, Sarah Virgin, Mary Rolfe, Elizabeth Woods, Lucinda M. S. Smith, Elizabeth Ray, Colman Godwin, Keziah Godwin, Henry Martin, Sarah Martin, John Thompson, Jane Thompson, Susan Adams, Sarah Brown, Maria Smith, Charlotte Adams, Francis Hemmenway, Rebecca Hemmenway, Phebe Dolly, Jeremiah Wheeler, Colman Hemmenway, David Elliot, Polly Elliot, Wm. Delano, Abigail A. Delano, Mary Martin, James Godwin, John Godwin, Clarissa Godwin, Lucinda Godwin, St. Luke Morse, Asa Graham, Wm. Frost, Wm. Bowen, James Silver, Azubah Abbot, Alice K. Parker, Judith Morse, Daniel Martin, Betsey Martin, Benj. Morse, Peter C. Virgin, Aaron Graham, Geneva Graham, George Graham, Hannah Graham, Samuel Farnum, Luther Trumbull, Lydia Knapp, Daniel Hall, Dolly Hall, Francis Keyes, Sally Virgin, Abigail Godwin, Milla Farnum, Hazen F. Abbot, Hannah Abbot, Polly Putnam, Louisa Farnum, Sarah Crockett, Edmund Abbot, George J. Farnum, John Farnum, Jr., Simeon F. Frost, Susan Farnum, Achsa Chamberlain, Mary A. Rolfe, Judith Rolfe, Sally B. Graham, Sarah P. Elliot, Maria C. L. Virgin, Catherine Virgin, Ruth Cleasby, Mahala F. Godwin, Chloe Holt, Virtue Howard, Betsey H. Harris, Dolly Frost, Abi Trumbull, Mary Abbot, Dolly Bolster, David Colby, Judith Colby, Susan Sheldon, Samuel S. Snow, Otis C. Bolster, Eliphalet S. Hopkins, Mary Anna Hopkins, Peter Thompson, Ajalon Godwin, Sarah S. Elliot, Malinda S. Elliot, David Holt, Wm. Morse, Francis Cushman, Lydia Cushman, Timothy Holt, Nancy Holt, Joseph Colby, Mary V. Colby, Mary S. Snow, Nathan W. Elliot, John S. Colby, Timothy D. Colby, Henry Abbot, Wm. H. Furness, Elizabeth A. Howe, Dolly M. Abbot, Hannah W. Martin, Lydia M. Carter, Wm. Moody, Mrs. Moody, Julian Smith, Sarah A. Martin, Jacob Elliot, Betsey Elliot, Sophia Stevens, Mary S. Dearborn, Elizabeth Thompson, Deborah Hutchins, Josiah G. Merrill, Harriet Merrill, Phebe M. Merrill, Josiah K. Elliot, John E. Elliot, Lucetta Abbot, Benjamin Elliot, Nahum P. Moody, Melville Silver, Melinda Moody, Bradbury Richardson, Euthalia W. Roberts, Lucinda G. Howe, Betsey Glines.
The following are the names of persons belonging to the church in August, eighteen hundred and eighty-one. Those marked with a star have since died: Sarah Martin, Hannah F. Abbot, Melinda S. Caldwell, Peter Thompson,* Henry Abbot, Nathan W. Elliot, Timothy Colby, Lydia Carter Elliot, Jane Martin Colby, Hannah W. M. Colby, Loammi B. Peabody,* William Moody,* Lucretia[p. 143]Abbot, J. Emery Elliot, Josiah K. Elliot, Charlotte K. Elliot,* Arabella B. Elliot, Lucinda G. Elliot, Isabel Martin, Harriet C. Ray, Jenette J. Peabody, Marie D. Elliot,* Emma A. Elliot, Arabella M. Elliot, Martha Elliot, Henrietta W. Smith, Mary M. Ray, Emma S. Atkinson, John F. Elliot, Edwin P. Smith, Charles D. Elliot, Edmund H. Elliot, John J. Elliot, Matthew H. Elliot, Robert T. Howard,* Charlotte M. Elliot, Isabelle Elliot, Georgiana B. Abbot, Dorothy D. Howard, Emma B. Pitcher, Pearl M. Elliot, Marshall A. Howard.